Quase caí pra trás quando li isso: um comentário de algum radical infeliz: Criticando até a morte o filme do PJ, q para mim ultrapassou a barreira do brilhantismo.. Leiam, está em inglês:
eu tava num site agora, e olha oq eu vi: um comentário totalmente estúpido sobre o Treceiro filme da trilogia.. com certeza algum fã radical do tolkien, está em inglês, olhem:
In short, a mockery of JRR's work.
That fat NZer has desecrated all that is sacred in Tolkien's work.
Remember people, that these movies are all that most people will ever know of Tolkien's creation, and PJ has taken so many artistic liberties with the story that it is unrecognisable.
This movie was wrong in every way, just wrong. It was far far worse that TTT which was wrong.
Frodo turned against sam!, Tolkien would be rolling in his grave.
The battles were all wrong, even down to the time of day and lighting. It seemed to me that PJ threw away many of the opportunities for spectacular scenes that JRR handed to him on a platter. The siege of Gondor for example seemed scattered and too fast, not the gruelling intense action described in the source material.
It certainly seems that the orcs have got sillier and siller looking throughout the trilogy. Leading the captain of Morgul to look like the ugly twin of the stay-puff marshmallow man.
And the Witch king wielded a mace for gods sake, not a bombing knocker (and a stupid looking one at that!)
And orcs never entered the city of Minas Tirith, they simply broke that gate. It was the witch king who alone entered and faced Gadnalf, there is an example of what could have been a tense scene, and it was not even included at all.
Too many scenes of Frodo and Sam crying, far too many.
As for Arwen, Tolkien didn't find her interesting enough to give much plot time to, and he was right. Time wasted with Arwens weepy close-ups could have been better spent on inclusion of scenes such as the mouth of Sauron, or Saruman, who were both glaringly not present.
PJ made so many stupid and un-needed changes that I can not list them all.
He has despoiled JRR work, and belittled it
Agora, depois desse absurdo, olhem como ele deu nota para cada quesito:
Elijah Wood's performance as Frodo Baggins? 1/5
Sean Astin's performance as Samwise Gamgee? 3/4
Billy Boyd's performance as Pippin Took? 3/5
Dominic Monaghan's performance as Merry Brandybuck? 3/4
Ian McKellen's performance as Gandalf? 3/4
Viggo Mortensen's performance as Aragorn? 4/4
Orlando Bloom's performance as Legolas? 3/4
John Rhys-Davies performance as Gimli? 4/4
Liv Tyler's performance as Arwen? 1
John Noble's performance as Denethor? 1
Bernard Hill's performance as Theoden? 1
Karl Urban's performance as Eomer? 3
Miranda Otto's performance as Eowyn? 2
David Wenham's performance as Faramir? 3
Andy Serkis's performance as Gollum? 2
How would you rate Peter Jackson in bringing The Return of the King to the Big Screen? 1
How would you rate the realism of the computer-generated creatures and armies of Middle-earth? 2
How would you rate the opening sequence with Smeagol and Deagol? 1
How would you rate the way in which Pippin discovers and reacts to the Palantir? 1
How would you rate the scenes with Frodo, Sam and Smeagol on the Cirith Ungol stair? 1
How would you rate the realization of Minas Tirith on screen? 4
How would you rate the decision to have Elrond deliver Anduril to Aragorn? 1
How would you rate Denethor's realization on screen? 1
How would you rate the Battle on the Pelennor Fields? 1
How would you rate the realization of Shelob on screen? 2
How would you rate the realization of the Armies of the Dead? 1
How would you rate the final sequence at Mt. Doom? 1
How would you rate the last stand at the Black Gates? 1
How would you rate the emotional effect of The Return of the King? 1
Acho q algumas pessoas não entedem que não dá pra simplesmente colocar o livro no cinema, tem q adatar, acrescentar certas coisas para a história não ficar sem nexo, retirar algumas coisas q atrapalharia o bom andamento do filme e mudar algumas partes pelo mesmo motivo... e o q mais me revoltou foi ele ter criticado tanto o John Noble no papel do Denthor.. foi uma das coisas q mais me agradou, para mim ele estava brilhante, só perdeu para o Ian Mckellen, q fez o Gandalf...
Afff, ele só podia estar morrendo de sono quando foi ver...
Tópico: Estou Revoltado... (Lida 7946 vezes)
